Our Cookie Menu

Soft Batch, Deep Dish Cookies "Chicago-Style" - Bigger, Thicker, & Richer Than A Normal Cookie

See our full restaurant menu including indulgent ice cream innovations here.

Cookies can be made gluten free upon special request.  Available gluten free cookies are noted with a

Chocolate Chip

The classic cookie but bigger, thicker, and tastier!

Sugar Cookie

Super-sized sugar cookie, painted with a light butter glaze and sprinkled with sugar crystals.


Chocolate chip cookie dough, baked with a layer of marshmallow, coated with decadent fudge, and sprinkled with crushed graham crackers.

Caramel Cookies & Cream

Cookie dough blended with crushed Oreo cookies and a caramel extract, an Oreo in into the center, drizzled with caramel.

Cookie Inception

A cookie… within a cookie… within a cookie… A chocolate chip cookie, topped with a layer of chocolate fudge, sprinkled with chocolate chip cookie bits and cookie dough balls.

Lemon Poppyseed

A sweet lemon taste with light crisp of a poppy seed throughout the fluffy cookie, drizzled with a citrus glaze.

Caramel Apple

Made from a specialty dough, swirled with caramel apple and salted caramel flavor, baked with a sprinkle of cinnamon, topped with icing, and dusted with apple powder.

Ultimate Peanut Butter

Peanut butter infused cookie dough is combined with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and Reese’s Pieces, decorated with melted peanut butter & showered chocolate flakes.

Ghost Cookie

Sugar cookie dough, baked with white chocolate chips inside, then topped with vanilla frosting and sugar flakes.

Nutella Stuffed

A savory hazelnut dough with a baked-in layer of Nutella, topped with mini dollops of Nutella and crispy pearls.

Blue Raz

An irresistible blue raspberry flavored sugar cookie, topped with a sweet cream glaze and blue sugar sprinkles.

Maple Bacon

A savory bacon and sweet maple syrup infused dough, topped with our sweet homemade icing & sprinkled with bacon bits.

Birthday Cake

A birthday cake flavored sugar cookie with baked in rainbow sprinkles, topped with vanilla frosting and rolled in rainbow sprinkles.

Salted Oreo Caramel Brownie

Chunks of Oreo baked into salted caramel and fudge batter, drizzled with more salted caramel and a sprinkle of sea salt.

Fudge Brownie

A soft fudge brownie with a sprinkle of powdered sugar.


A soft cinnamon flavored cookie with swirls of cinnamon ripples throughout.

Pecan Maple

A flavorful maple cookie with baked in pecan pieces, and topped with a sweet maple-vanilla drizzle.


Fall Seasonal Specials

Pumpkin Spice

A soft pumpkin based cookie topped with nutmeg buttercream frosting. A seasonal favorite.


Other Seasonal Specials

Turtle Brownie

A chocolate chip cookie, scooped out into a bowl form and filled with brownie batter and walnuts, then drizzled with sweet caramel.


Rainbow Brownie

Fudge brownie baked into the center of a chocolate chip cookie, and topped with M&M’s.

Key Lime Krunch

Sugar cookie dough infused with key lime flavoring, baked with marshmallow topped with a lime drizzle and granola bits.

Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint flavored chocolate chip cookie with baked in Andes Mints.

Red Velvet

A soft red velvet cookie with cream cheese frosting, rolled in red sugar crystals.


A cool peppermint cookie, with candy cane pieces baked in, rolled in peppermint dust


Send a box of Innovative Indulgences cookies as a gift! We offer elegantly wrapped gift box packages to be locally hand delivered for special occasions. Share this delicious treat with your family and friends, and include a free card with a special personalized message. Gift boxes are individually wrapped in decorative paper and tied with a matching ribbon.


For larger orders or events, contact us for party tray pricing and delivery. Or see our events page for our fully staffed warm cookie sundae bar and indulgent ice cream stand.

Share This